Issue 2 (20) 2013

CONSTITUTIONKhudoleyKM ALITY OF DECISIONS ECHR AND THEIR FEASIBILITY

CONSTITUTIONALITY OF DECISIONS ECHR AND THEIR FEASIBILITY

K.M. Khudoley

Perm State National Research University
15, Bukirev st., Perm, 614990
E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

In given article the problem of execution of decisions of the European court of human rights in case of their discrepancy of decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation is considered. The problem of conformity of decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the ECHR became actual after acceptance by these courts of justice of various decisions on sense at Markin's legal investigation and affairs of Republican Party of Russia. With a view of bar of claim by lapse of time of repetition of a similar situation a number of authors acts with idea to give Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation to solve a question on feasibility of decisions of ECHR in case of its contradiction of the Constitution of the Russian Federation. The author analyzes positions federal and the legislation and practice of the constitutional justice, and also practice of activity of ECHR. The author the conclusion that decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the European Court under human rights should be understood in aspect of varying politiko-legal conditions becomes. The contradiction between certificates of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the European court under human rights can be caused various the reason owing to what blocking of decisions ECHR by the Russian constitutional court is hardly proved. In work the conclusion becomes, that the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the ECHR should be more constrained in an estimation of some facts, and their activity should be under construction on the basis of mutual respect and the account of legal positions.

Keywords: constitution interpretation; interpretation of the constitutional positions; the constitutional court; the European court of human rights; political party; political party liquidation; the right to holiday; constitutionality of decisions ECHR; execution of decisions ECHR; the interpretation certificate

Bibliograficheskij spisok

1. Aleksandr Torshin otlozhil Evrosud na osen' // Kommersant#. 2011. 18 ijulja.

2. Bjulleten' Evropejskogo suda po pravam cheloveka. 2010. № 11. S. 31-34.

3. Vedomosti VS SSSR. 1986. № 37. St. 772.

4. Zor'kin V.D. Predel ustupchivosti // Ros. gaz. 2010. 29 okt.

5. Konvencija o zashhite prav cheloveka i osnovnyh svobod: zakl. v Rime 4 nojabrja 1950 g., (s izm. ot 13.05.2004) // Bjul. mezhdunar. dogovorov. 2001. №3.

6. Konvencija o pravah rebenka: odobr. Gener. Assamblej OON 20 nojab. 1989 g.) // Sb. mezhdunar. dogovorov SSSR. 1993. Vyp. XLVI.

7. Konstitucija Rossijskoj Federacii [prinjata vsenar. golosovaniem 12 dek. 1993 g. (v red . ot 30.12.2008)] // Ros. gaz. 1993. 25 dek.

8. Kokotov A.N. Nasushhnye voprosy regulirovanija dejatel'nosti Konstitucionnogo Suda Rossijskoj Federacii // Ros. jurid. zhurnal. 2012. №2. S. 20–27.

9. Krjazhkov V.A. Konstitucionnoe pravosudie v sub#ektah Rossijskoj Federacii (pravovye osnovy i praktika). M.: Formula prava, 1999. 768 s.

10. Ob otkaze v prinjatii k rassmotreniju zhalob grazhdanina Markina Konstantina Aleksandrovicha na narushenie ego konstitucionnyh prav polozhenijami statej 13 i 15 Federal'nogo zakona «O gosudarstvennyh posobijah grazhdanam, imejushhim detej», statej 10 i 11 Federal'nogo zakona «O statuse voennosluzhashhih», stat'i 32 Polozhenija o porjadke prohozhdenija voennoj sluzhby i punktov 35 i 44 Polozhenija o naznachenii i vyplate gosudarstvennyh posobij grazhdanam, imejushhim detej» [Jelektronnyj resurs]: opredelenie Konstituc. suda RF ot 15 janv. 2009 g. №187-O-O. Dokument opublikovan ne byl. Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoj sistemy «Konsul'tantPljus».

11. O Konstitucionnom Sude Rossijskoj Federacii: Feder. konstituc. zakon ot 21 ijulja 1994 g. №1-FKZ (red. ot 28.12.2010) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 1994. №13, st. 1447.

12. O vnesenii izmenenij v otdel'nye zakonodatel'nye akty Rossijskoj Federacii: proekt feder. konstituc. zakona №564346-5. Dokument opublikovan ne byl. Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoj sistemy «Konsul'tantPljus».

13. O nekotoryh merah sovershenstvovanija dejatel'nosti Konstitucionnogo Suda Respubliki Belarus': dekret Prezidenta Respubliki Belarus' ot 26 ijunja 2008 g. URL: http:// www.spinform.ru/show_doc.fwx?rgn=23421 (data obrashhenija: 25.01.2013).

14. Po delu o proverke konstitucionnosti abzacev vtorogo i tret'ego punkta 2 stat'i 3 i punkta 6 stat'i 47 Federal'nogo zakona «O politicheskih partijah» v svjazi s zhaloboj obshhestvenno-politicheskoj organizacii «Baltijskaja respublikanskaja partija»: postanovlenie Konstituc. suda RF ot 1 fevr. 2005 g. №1-P // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 2005. №6, st. 491.

15. Po delu o proverke konstitucionnosti otdel'nyh polozhenij statej 3, 18 i 41 Federal'nogo zakona «O politicheskih partijah» v svjazi s zhaloboj politicheskoj partii «Rossijskaja kommunisticheskaja rabochaja partija – Rossijskaja partija kommunistov»: postanovlenie Konstituc. suda RF ot 16 ijulja 2007 g. №11-P // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 2007. №30, st. 3989.

16. Po zhalobe Dudnik Margarity Viktorovny na narushenie ee konstitucionnyh prav chast'ju pervoj stat'i 79 Federal'nogo konstitucionnogo zakona «O Konstitucionnom Sude Rossijskoj Federacii»: opredelenie Konstituc. suda RF ot 13 janvarja 2000 g. №6-O // VKS RF. 2000. №2.

17. Poslanie Prezidenta RF Federal'nomu Sobraniju ot 6 nojabrja 2008 goda // Ros. gaz. 2008. 6 nojab.

18. Poslanie Prezidenta RF Federal'nomu Sobraniju ot 22 dekabrja 2011 goda // Ros. gaz. 2011.23 dek.

19. Sobranie zakonodatel'stva Rossijskoj Federacii. 1998. №14, st. 1514.

20. Churov V.E., Jebzeev B.S. Reshenie ESPCh po delu «Respublikanskaja partija Rossii protiv Rossii», ili Utrachennye illjuzii // Konstituc. i municip. pravo. 2011. №12. S. 2–11.

21. URL: http://www.espch.ru/content/view/7136 (data obrashhenija: 25.01.2013).

22. URL: http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cqi/online.cqi?res=doc;base=arb;n=233192 (data obrashhenija: 25.01.2013).