Issue 3 (13) 2011

LEGISLATIVE ROLE OF REGIONS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION IN DEFINITION OF CASES OF WITHDRAWAL OF THE GROUND AREAS FOR THE STATE OR MUNICIPAL NEEDS

LEGISLATIVE ROLE OF REGIONS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION IN DEFINITION OF CASES OF WITHDRAWAL OF THE GROUND AREAS FOR THE STATE OR MUNICIPAL NEEDS

A.A. Kulakova

Perm State National Research University

15, Bukireva st., Perm, 614990

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.  

The article deals with the analysis of additional cases of redemption of the land plot for the state and municipal needs established in laws of regions of the Russian Federation. Problems of interaction of the Russian Federation and regions of the Russian Federation concerning possession, using and the order by the land, differentiations of the civil and land legislation are covered. Exclusive character of state (municipal) objects which are provided by the regional legislator as the basis of redemption of the land plot for public needs in documents of land-use planning is estimated. The role of land-use planning documents is described. Among analyzed objects – objects of housing construction activity, stadiums, hospitals, schools, kindergartens, other social objects, which go a long way for people. Regional laws are characterized from the point of view of legal owners whose premises are to be taken away in connection with public needs. It is very important to consider their interests. The author of article results positions of the Concept of real right legislation development which regulates grounds for termination of the right of property, and agrees with authors of the Concept regarding that norms about the rights to the ground areas, about a turn of the ground areas are considered as norms not land, but the civil legislation. The author comes to a conclusion about necessity of regulation grounds for termination of the right of land property by the civil legislation which is in conducting the Russian Federation. In such situation possibility of an establishment of additional cases redemption of the land plot will be excluded from conducting regions of the Russian Federation. It undoubtedly is a perspective stage in development of institute of withdrawal of the ground areas for public needs since legitimate interests of legal land owners will be in a greater degree guaranteed. Definiteness and predictability of public power actions is a condition of stability of a civil circulation.

Keywords: cases of redemption of the land plot for the state and municipal needs; joint conducting the Russian Federation and regions of the Russian Federation; objects of the state or municipal value; objects of housing construction; exclusive character of withdrawal; the Concept of real right legislation development

Bibliograficheskij spisok

1. Anisimov A.L., Ryzhenkov A.Ja., Sotnikova L.S. Pravo municipal'noj sobstvennosti na zemel'nye uchastki v Rossijskoj Federacii: voprosy teorii i praktiki: monografija. M.: Novyj indeks, 2010. 255s.

2. Zemel'nyj kodeks Rossijskoj Federacii: Feder.zakon Ros.Federacii ot 25 okt. 2001 g. №136-FZ (red. ot 19.07.2011 g. №246-FZ) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federfcii. 2001. №44, st. 4147.

3. Kabytov N.L. Vykup zemel'nogo uchastka kak osnovanie prekrawenija prava chastnoj sobstvennosti: dis. ... kand. jurid. nauk. Samara, 2004. 214 s.

4. Kamyshanskij V.P., Kamyshanskij A.V., Arakel'jan R.G. Rezervirovanie i iz#jatie zemel'nyh uchastkov dlja municipal'nyh nuzhd // Zakon. №1. 2007. S. 64–73.

5. Kamyshanskij V.P. Rezervirovanie zemel' poselenij dlja municipal'nyh nuzhd pri osuwestvlenii gradostroitel'noj dejatel'nosti// Zhiliwnoe pravo. 2006. №9. Dostup iz sprav.- pravovoj sistemy «Konsul'tantPljus».

6. Koncepcija razvitija zakonodatel'stva o vewnom prave [Jelektronnyj resurs]. URL: http//www.privlaw.m/vs info4.html (data obrawenija: 31.08.2011).

7. Krasjukova A.S. Osuwestvlenie prava sobstvennosti na zemel'nye uchastki poselenij: predely i ogranichenija. Dis. ...kand.jurid.nauk. Krasnodar, 2006. 204 s.

8. Lavrova Ju. Prekrawenie vewnyh prav na zemel'nye uchastki v Koncepcii razvitija zakonodatel'stva o vewnom prave // Hozjajstvo i pravo. 2010. №1. S. 85–91.

9. Lisica V.I. Pravovoe obespechenie realizacii prioritetnogo nacional'nogo proekta «Dostupnoe i komfortnoe zhil'e – grazhdanam Rossii» // Zhiliwnoe pravo. 2007. №11. Dostup iz sprav.- pravovoj sistemy «Konsul'tantPljus».

10. Ob iz#jatii zemel'nyh uchastkov i zhilyh domov dlja stroitel'stva novogo zhil'ja». Fond «Institut jekonomiki goroda [Jelektronnyj resurs]: Analiticheskaja zapiska. URL:http://www.urbaneconomics.ru/publications/?mat_id=347 (data obrawenija: 31.08.2011).

11. O zemle: zakon Respubliki Dagestan ot 29 dek. 2003 g. №45 (red. ot 06.05.2011 g. №25) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Respubliki Dagestan. 2003. №12, st. 924.

12. O predostavlenii i iz#jatii zemel'nyh uchastkov v Tomskoj oblasti: zakon Tomskoj oblasti ot 04 okt. 2002 g. №74-OZ (red. ot 08.08.2011 g. №162-OZ) // Ofic. vedomosti Gosudarstvennoj Dumy Tomskoj oblasti. 2002. №11(72).

13. O regulirovanii zemel'nyh otnoshenij: zakon respubliki Ingushetija ot 14 dek. 2007 №50-RZ (red. ot 31.12.2010 g. №68-RZ) // Ingushetija. 2007. №161.

14. O regulirovanii zemel'nyh otnoshenij v respublike Bashkortostan: zakon Respubliki Bashkortostan ot 5 janv. 2004 g. №59-z (red. ot 20.05.2011 g. №397-3) // Respublika Bashkortostan. 2004. №29 (25512).

15. O regulirovanii zemel'nyh otnoshenij na territorii Vladimirskoj oblasti: zakon Vladimirskoj oblasti ot 11 marta 2010 g. №11-OZ (red. ot 06.06.2011 g. №38-OZ) // Vladimir. vedomosti. 2010. №64.

16. O regulirovanii zemel'nyh otnoshenij na territorii Voronezhskoj oblasti: zakon Voronezh. obl. ot 13 maja 2008 g. №25-OZ (red. ot 11.07.2011 g. №108-OZ) // Molodoj kommunar. 2008. №52.

17. O regulirovanii zemel'nyh otnoshenij na territorii respubliki Mordovija: zakon Respubliki Mordovija ot 12 marta 2009 g. №23-3 (red. ot 05.05.2011 g. №18-3) // Izvestija Mordovii. 2009. №35-7.

18. O regulirovanii otdel'nyh zemel'nyh otnoshenij v Tul'skoj oblasti: zakon Tul'skoj obl. ot 12 nojab. 2007 g. №898-ZTO (red. ot 20.07.2011 g. №1625-ZTO) // Tul'skie izvestija. 2007. №225.

19. O sovershenstvovanii Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federacii: ukaz Prezidenta Ros. Federacii ot 18 ijulja 2008 g. №1108 // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 2008. №29 (ch. 1), st. 3482.

20. Ob oborote zemel' sel'skohozjajstvennogo naznachenija: Feder. zakon Ros. Federacii ot 24 ijulja 2002 g. №101-FZ (red. ot 29.12.2010 g. №435-FZ) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva RF. 29.07.2002. №30, st. 3018.

21. Ob obwih principah organizacii zakonodatel'nyh (predstavitel'nyh) i ispolnitel'nyh organov gosudarstvennoj vlasti sub#ektov Rossijskoj Federacii: Feder. zakon Ros. Federacii ot 6 okt. 1999 g. №184-FZ (red. ot 25.07.2011 g. №263-FZ) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 1999. №42, st. 5005.

22. Ob obwih principah organizacii mestnogo samoupravlenija v Rossijskoj Federacii: Feder. zakon Ros. Federacii ot 6. okt. 2003 g. №131-F3 (red. ot 25.07.2011 g. №263-FZ) //Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 2003. №40, st. 3822.

23. Ob osnovah regulirovanija zemel'nyh otnoshenij v Krasnodarskom krae: akon Krasnodar. kraja ot 5 nojab. 2002 g. №532-KZ (red. ot 19.07.2011 g. №2317-KZ) // Kubanskie novosti. 2002. №240.

24. Ob otdel'nyh voprosah pravovogo regulirovanija zemel'nyh otnoshenij v Astrahanskoj oblasti: zakon Astrah. obl. ot 4 marta 2008 g. №7/2008-03 (red. ot 19.07.2011 g. №43/2011-OZ) // Sb. zakonov i norm.-prav. aktov Astrah. obl. 2008. №11.

25. Ob ustanovlenii sluchaev iz#jatija, v tom chisle putem vykupa, zemel'nyh uchastkov iz zemel', nahodjawihsja v sobstvennosti Ivanovskoj oblasti ili municipal'noj sobstvennosti, dlja gosudarstvennyh nuzhd oblasti ili municipal'nyh nuzhd: zakon Ivan. obl. ot 29 dek. 2008 №174-OZ (red. ot 29.12.2010 g. №158-03) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ivan. obl. 2009. №2(422).

26. Pavlova O.V., Vasil'chuk Ju.V. Zemel'nye otnoshenija na regional'nom urovne: zakon i praktika // Zakonodatel'stvo. 2008. №6. S. 63–68.

27. Sidorova E.L. Balans publichnyh i chastnyh interesov pri iz#jatii zemel'nyh uchastkov dlja gosudarstvennyh ili municipal'nyh nuzhd // Zhurnal ros. prava. №4. 2010. S. 140–147.

28. Syrunina T. Konstitucionnye garantii prava sobstvennosti pri iz#jatii imuwestva dlja publichnyh nuzhd: jekonomicheskij analiz (na primere sudebnoj praktiki (SShA) // Sravnitel'noe konstituc. obozrenie. 2009. №5(72). S. 25–38.

29. Torkin D. Iz#jatie zemel'nyh uchastkov dlja gosudarstvennyh nuzhd s cel'ju zhiliwnogo stroitel'stva // Hozjajstvo i pravo. 2009. №6. S. 27–30.

30. Jejrijan G.N. Razgranichenie polnomochij mezhdu RF i ee sub#ektami v sfere regulirovanija zemel'nyh otnoshenij // Zhurnal ros. prava. 2006. №3. Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoj sistemy «Konsul'tant-Pljus».

31. Jakushev B.C. Grazhdanskoe zakonodatel'stvo i zakonodatel'stvo sub#ektov Federacii // Ros. jurid. zhurnal. 2001. №1. S. 39–44.