Issue 4 (14) 2011

4 LAW AND SUBORDINATE REGULATORY LEGAL ACT: PROBLEMS OF CORRELATION

LAW AND SUBORDINATE REGULATORY LEGAL ACT: PROBLEMS OF CORRELATION

D.G. Morozov

Kuibyshevsky district court in St. Petersburg
20, Karavannaya st., St. Petersburg, 191023
E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

 

In this article is debatating a question about a law and regulatory of legal act parity in all territory of the Russian Federation considered. The law as a source of the right existed in the most ancient states. Laws regulate the most important public relations and interactions, they are steady, stable and have a relative invariance. The highest validity of laws is expressed that all other standard legal certificates in the state should be published on the basis of laws, and can't contradict with them. All in all, the understanding of a parity of the law and subordinate statutory act in Soviet period proceeded in practice mainly from that there is not single law that could operate without the whole system concretizing and developing it's subordinate statutory acts.

Therefore begins the importance for a lawful state to regulate all questions, especially questions which mention the rights, freedom and duties, the law and only the law. The law and subordinate standard legal certificate are the basic versions of one source of the right − the standard legal certificate.

However, the granted source of the right − not unique in legal system of the Russian Federation. Any all-round theoretical researches on problems of a parity of the law and subordinate standard legal certificate in our country was not done. In the same time one of conditions formation of a lawful state is the presence of coordinated and consistented legislation. In this article it is mentioned that the problem of artificial increase of a role and legal effect of subordinate act rather than the act of legislation. There is an important question which has necessity in the definition an optimum parity of the law and subordinate normative legal act with definition of hierarchical dependence degree and subordination of subordinate normative legal act in relation to the law, and also establishment subject spheres of regulation compared to the acts.

Increase of a role of the law in the conditions of transformation state-legal relations is proved due to the fact of necessity improvement of the laws quality and their efficiency.

Keywords: court; norms of the right; state (government); right; law; supremacy of law; principles of right

Bibliograficheskijj spisok

1. Vishnevskijj E.V. Uchebnik grazhdanskogo processa. M., 1914. S. 18.

2. David R. Osnovnye pravovye sistemy sovremennosti. M.: Progress, 1988. 496 s.

3. Ivanov S.A. Sootnoshenie zakona i podzakonnogo akta: avtoref. dis. … kand. jurid. nauk. M., 2001. 23 s.

4. Kirin V.A. K voprosu o sootnoshenii obshhesojuznogo i respublikanskogo zakonodatel'stva (na opyte ugolovnogo zakonodatel'stva) // Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo. 1963. №8. S. 111–122.

5. Korkunov N.M. Ukaz i zakon. SPb.: Tip. M.M. Stasjulevicha, 1894. 416 c.

6. Kuznecov I.N. K voprosu o juridicheskojj prirode Ukaza Prezidiuma Verkhovnogo Soveta i ego sootnoshenii s zakonom // Voprosy sovetskogo gosudarstvennogo prava. M., 1959. S. 252.

7. Lazarev L.V. O sootnoshenii zakona i ukaza // Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo. 1965. №5. S. 62–69.

8. Lifshic Ju.P. Kriterii ocenki konstitucionnosti normativnykh aktov. M.: IGP RAN, 1994. S. 5.

9. Lokk Dzh. Dva traktata o pravlenii: soch.: v 3 t. M.: Mysl', 1988. T. 2, kn. 2.

10. Luchin V.O., Mazurov A.V. Ukazy Prezidenta Rossijjskojj Federacii: osnovnye social'nye i pravovye kharakteristiki. M.: JuNITI-DANA, 2000. 303 s.

11. Mickevich A.V. Akty vysshikh organov Sovetskogo gosudarstva (Juridicheskaja priroda normativnykh aktov vysshikh organov gosudarstvennojj vlasti i upravlenija SSSR). M.: Nauka, 1968. 175 s.

12. Montesk'e Sh.L. O dukhe zakonov, ili ob otnoshenijakh, v kotorykh zakony dolzhny nakhodit'sja, k ustrojjstvu kazhdogo pravlenija, k nravam, klimatu, religii i torgovle i t.d. SPb.: Izd-vo L.F. Panteleeva, 1900. 800s.

13. Muravskijj V.A. Zakon i aktual'noe pravo v pravovykh sistemakh stran Drevnego mira: preprint. Ekaterinburg: Izd-vo URO RAN, 2006. 608 s.

14. Nozdrachev A.F. Predely konkretizacii zakonov i podzakonnykh aktov ministerstvami i vedomstvami Sojuza SSR (po materialam funkcional'nykh ministerstv i vedomstv Sojuza SSR) // Uchen. zap. VNIISZ. 1968. Vyp. 12.

15. O porjadke opublikovanija i vstuplenija v silu federal'nykh konstitucionnykh zakonov, federal'nykh zakonov, aktov palat Federal'nogo sobranija: Feder. zakon Ros. Federacii ot 14 ijunja 1994 g. №5-FZ // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva Rossijjskojj Federacii. 1995. №8. St. 801

16. Pigolkin A.S. Teoreticheskie problemy pravotvorcheskojj dejatel'nosti v SSSR: avtoref. dis. … d-ra jurid. nauk. M., 1972. 23 s.

17. Pigolkin A.S. O sootnoshenii zakonov i ukazov Prezidenta v Rossijjskojj Federacii // Vestnik mezhparlamentskojj assamblei. 1995. №1. S. 36–41.

18. Popova V.I. Sootnoshenie aktov Soveta Ministrov sojuznojj respubliki s aktami drugikh organov gosudarstvennogo upravlenija: avtoref. dis. …d-ra jurid. nauk. M., 1973. S. 18–19.

19. Russo Zh.-Zh. Ob Obshhestvennom dogovore, ili Principy politicheskogo Prava / per. s fr. A.D. Khajutina i V.S. Alekseeva-Popova. M.: KANON-press: Kuchkovo pole, 1998. 416 s.

20. Samoshhenko I.S. Ierarkhija i osnovnye podrazdelenija normativnykh aktov socialisticheskogo gosudarstva // Uchen. zap. VNIISZ. 1968. №15. S. 3–17.

21. Tikhomirov Ju.A. Kriterii konstitucionnosti pravovykh aktov. // Vestnik Konstitucionnogo Suda Rossijjskojj Federacii. 1996. №6. S. 35–41.

22. Tikhomirov Ju.A. Teorija zakona. M.: Nauka, 1982. 257 s.

23. Cvik M.V. O podzakonnosti ukazov Prezidiuma Verkhovnogo soveta SSSR // Uchen. zap. Khar'k. jurid. in-ta. 1956. Vyp. 7. S. 30–31.

24. Shershenevich G.F. Obshhaja teorija prava: ucheb. posobie: v 2 t. M., 1995. T. 2. S. 89 (reprintnoe izdanie).