Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2020. Issue 2 (48)

Title: 'ESTATE PLANNING' AND SELECTION OF A HEREDITARY ORDER
Authors:

E. A. Khodyreva, Udmurt State University

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
ORCID: 0000-0001-6767-2387 ResearcherID: A-9297-2020
Articles of «Scopus» & «Web of Science»:       ---
Requisites: Khodyreva E. A. 'Estate Planning' i vybor suprugami vida nasledstvennogo rasporyazheniya ['Estate Planning' and the Selection of an Inheritance Order]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2020. Issue 48. Pp. 364–387. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2020-48-364-387
DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2020-48-364-387
Annotation:

Introduction: the article analyzes the types of posthumous inheritance orders that spouses can choose according to the norms of Russian legislation. The introduction of new types of the orders - a joint will and an inheritance agreement - makes the tasks of researching them, comparing them with the traditional, ‘classical’ will, and identifying the most efficient method of estate planning extremely relevant. Purpose: based on the analysis of doctrinal sources, norms of the current Russian and foreign legislation, practice of their application, to determine the main criteria that should be followed by spouses when choosing the type of inheritance order.
Methods: general scientific and special scientific research methods were employed: formal and dialectical logic, methods of describing, comparing, interpreting, legal-dogmatic, historical methods, and the method of interpretation of legal norms. Results: analysis of the current legislation showed that a number of provisions of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation on joint wills and inheritance agreements require more detailed study and clarification. All the types of posthumous inheritance orders established by law are aimed at the realization by citizens of the right of inheritance and are guaranteed by the norms of the current legislation. However, it turned out impossible to guarantee unhindered exercise of the right of inheritance, on the one hand, and to ensure the interconnectedness of the will in a joint testament or inheritance agreement, on the other hand. Therefore, the legislator made its choice in favor of freedom of the will. Conclusions: when spouses choose the type of inheritance order, their own interest and the goals they want to achieve are of decisive importance. In terms of the content and terms, the inheritance agreement is more diverse as compared to the will and joint will. However, none of the types of posthumous orders can guarantee the receipt by the heir of the property indicated in the will, including the joint will, or in the inheritance agreement. In such a situation, inter vivos methods of disposition of property appear to be more preferable.

Keywords: inheritance orders; inheritance agreement; joint will; spouses; fulfillment of obligations; conditional orders; amendment and cancellation of orders; right to unilateral refusal 
  download the full-version article
References: 1. Barshchevskiy M. Yu. Esli otkrylos' nasledstvo... [If an Inheritance Is Opened...]. Moscow, 1989. 192 p. (In Russ.).
2. Vol'man I. S., Markov N. O., Mogilevskiy M. O., Nikol'skiy D. P. Grazhdanskoe pravo [Civil Law]. St. Petersburg, 1903. 232 p. (In Russ.).
3. Grishaev S.P. Nasledstvennoe pravo: Uchebnoe posobie [Inheritance Law: Study Guide]. Moscow, 2002. 125 p. (In Russ.).
4. Zakon o nasledovanii. Grazhdanskoe zakonodatel'stvo Izrailya [Inheritance Act. Israeli Civil Law]. St. Petersburg, 2003. 633 p. (In Russ.).
5. Informatsiya o tarifakh i stavkakh za okazanie uslug pravovogo i tekhnicheskogo kharaktera za sovershenie notarial'nykh deystviy [Information on Tariffs and Rates for the Provision of Legal and Technical Services in Performing Notarial Actions]. Available at: http://39.notariat.ru/ ru-ru/help/tablica-tarifov-za-sovershenie-nota¬rial¬nyh-dejstvij (accessed 29.01.2020). (In Russ.).
6. Kommentariy k Grazhdanskomu kodeksu Rossiyskoy Federatsii. Chast' tret'ya (postateynyy) / otv. red. L. P. Anufrieva [Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Part Three (Itemized); ed. by L. P. Anufrieva]. Moscow, 2004. 656 p. (In Russ.).
7. Kurdinovskiy V. I. Dogovory o prave nasledovaniya [Contracts on Inheritance]. Zapiski Imperatorskogo Novorossiyskogo universiteta Yuridicheskogo fakul'teta / pod red. A. P. Dobroklonskogo [Proceedings of the Imperial Novorossiysk University, Faculty of Law; ed. by A. P. Dobroklonskiy]. Odessa, 1912. Issue 9. 322 p. (In Russ.).
8. Meyer D. I. Russkoe grazhdanskoe pravo (v 2 ch.) [Russian Civil Law (in 2 pts.)]. Moscow, 2000. 831 p. (In Russ.).
9. Novitskiy I. B. Rimskoe pravo. Uchebnik dlya vuzov [Roman Law. Textbook for Universities]. Moscow, 2002. 256 p. (In Russ.).
10. Osnovnye instituty grazhdanskogo prava zarubezhnykh stran [The Main Institutions of Civil Law in Foreign Countries]. Moscow, 2000. 648 p. (In Russ.).
11. Sklovskiy K. I. Sdelka i ee deystvie. Kommentariy glavy 9 GK RF (ponyatie, vidy i forma sdelok. Nedeystvitel'nost' sdelok) [Transaction and Its Effect. Commentary on the Chapter 9 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation (Concept, Types and Form of Transactions. Invalidity of Transactions)]. Moscow, 2015. 176 p. Access from the legal reference system 'ConsultantPlus'. (In Russ.).
12. Slepakova A. V. Pravootnosheniya sob¬st¬vennosti suprugov [Legal Relationship of Spouses' Property]. Moscow, 2005. 444 p. Access from the legal reference system 'ConsultantPlus'. (In Russ.).
13. Telyukina M. V. Nasledstvennoe pravo: Kommentariy Grazhdanskogo Kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii: Uchebno-prakt. posobie. [Inheritance Law: Commentary on the Civil Code of the Russian Federation: Study Guide]. Moscow, 2002. 216 p. (In Russ.).
14. Trepitsyn I. N. Grazhdanskoe pravo. Chast' II: Obyazatel'stvennoe pravo. Semeystvennoe pravo i Nasledstvennoe pravo: Zapiski po lektsiyam prof. I. N. Trepitsyna [Civil Law. Part II: Law of Obligations. Family Law and Inheritance Law: Notes Based on Lectures by Professor I. N. Trepitsyn]. Warsaw, 1914. 36 p. (In Russ.).
15. Cesare S. Kurs rimskogo chastnogo prava: uchebnik pod red. D. V. Dozhdeva [Course of Roman Private Law: Textbook; ed. by D. V. Dozhdev]. Moscow, 2002. 400 p. (In Russ.).
16. Khodyreva E. A. Sovremennoe sostoyanie i perspektivy razvitiya zakonodatel'stva ob uslovnykh posmertnykh rasporyazheniyakh [Current State and Prospects for the Development of Legislation on Conditional Posthumous Orders]. Nauchnye trudy. Rossiyskaya akademiya yuridicheskikh nauk; otv. red. V. V. Grib. [Scientific Works. Russian Academy of Legal Sciences; ed. by V. V. Grib]. Moscow, 2017. Issue17. Vol. 2. Pp. 168–174. (In Russ.).
17. Khodyreva E. A. Pravo nasledovaniya na osnovanii sovmestnogo zaveshchaniya v svete reformirovaniya zakonodatel'stva o nasledovanii: spornye voprosy [The Controversial Issues of Implementation of the Right of Inheritance on the Basis of the Joint Testament in the Light of the Reform of the Legislation on Inheritance]. Notarial'nyy vestnik" – Notary Bulletin. 2016. Issue 12. Pp. 37–44. (In Russ.).
18. Shershenevich G. F. Kurs grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Course]. Tula, 2001. 720 p. (In Russ.).
19. Yakovlev V. N. Drevnerimskoe chastnoe pravo i sovremennoe rossiyskoe grazhdanskoe pravo: uchebnik [Ancient Roman Private Law and Modern Russian Civil Law: Textbook]. Moscow, 2010. 960 p. (In Russ.).
20. Bornhauser Ph.. Inheritance Contracts under Swiss Law: A Valuable and Binding Instrument for International Estates. Available at: https://www.umbricht.ch/fileadmin/downloads/Born-hauser_Inheritance_contracts_under_Swiss_law__ A_valuable_and_binding_instrument_for_international_estates.pdf (accessed 24.01.2020). (In Eng.).
21. Brouwer K. Der Erbvertrag – die Sichere Alternative zum Testament. Available at: https://www.advocado.de/ratgeber/erbrecht/erbfolge/der-erbvertrag-die-sichere-alternative-zum-testament.html (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Germ.).
22. Der Erbvertrag. Available at: https://www.ro¬separtner.de /erbvertrag.html (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Germ.).
23. Erbvertrag und Erbschaftssteuer: So Regeln Immobilienbesitzer Ihren Nachlass. Available at: https://ratgeber.immowelt.de/a/erbvertrag-und-er¬bschaftssteuer-so-regeln-immobilienbesitzer-ihren-nachlass.html (accessed 22.01.2020). (In Germ.).
24. Erbvertrag: Eine Sinnvolle Alternative zum Testament? Available at: https://www.im-mo¬ver-kauf24.de/immobilienverkauf/erbschaft/er-brecht/erbvertrag (accessed 23.01.2020). (In Germ.)
25. Erbrechtliche Vorsorge. Available at: https://www.erbrecht.de/Ratsuchende/Erbrechtliche_Vorsorge/ (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Germ.).
26. Estate Planning. Available at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estate_planning (accessed 03.12.2019). (In Eng.).
27. Gemeinsames Testament. Available at: https://berlinertestament.net/gemeinsames-testament/ (accessed 22.01.2020). (In Germ.).
28. Gesetz über die Eingetragene Lebenspartnerschaft. Available at: http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/lpartg/index.html#BJNR026610001BJ NE001003308 (accessed 22.01.2020). (In Germ.).
29. How Can I Regulate Succession to My Estate? Available at: https://www.ch.ch/en/how-can-i-regulate-succession-to-my-estate/ (accessed 24.01.2020). (In Eng.).
30. JusNet Erbrecht. Auskunftsanspruch des übergangenen Pflichtteilsgeschützten Erben. Available at: https://erbrecht.iusnet.ch/de/recht-sprechung/kanton/nachlassabwicklung/auskunfts¬an¬spruch-des-%C3%BCbergangenen-pflicht-teilsgesch%C3%BCtzten/¬ (accessed 30.01.2020). (In Germ.).
31. Kagan J. Mutual Will. Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/mutual-will.asp (accessed 23.01.2020). (In Eng.).
32. Kapp T. Erbvertrag oder Testament: So Vererben Sie Richtig. Available at: https://www.haus¬frage.de/erbvertrag/ (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Germ.).
33. Klinger V., Frank J.-H. Gemeinschaftliches Testament: Widerruf, Bindungswirkung und Wirkung der Scheidung. Available at: https://www.wf-frank.com/detail/article/gemein¬schaft¬liches-testament-widerruf-bindungswirkung-und-wirkung-der-scheidung-1599.html (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Germ.).
34. Last Will and Testament Pricing. Available at: https://www.legalzoom.com/personal/estate-planning/last-will-and-testament-pricing.html (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Eng.).
35. Mutual Wills: Should You Have Them? Available at: https://www.clarkewillmott.com/ news/mutual-wills-should-you-have-them/ (acces¬sed 23.01.2020). (In Eng.).
36. Naukovo-praktichniy komentar Tsivіl'¬no¬go kodeksu Ukraїni [Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Civil Code of Ukraine]. Vol. 2 (Current). Available at: https://www.me¬go.info/ матеріал/стаття-1243-заповіт-подружжя (acces¬sed 20.01.2020). (In Ukr.).
37. Randolph M. How Much Will a Lawyer Charge to Write Your Will? Available at: https://www.nolo.com/law-authors/mary-randolph.html (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Eng.).
38. Rheinisches Museum. Jahrgang 2. Heft 2. Pp. 150–151 [Cit. ex: Kurdinovskiy V. I. Dogovory o prave nasledovaniya [Contracts on Inheritance]. Zapiski Imperatorskogo Novorossiyskogo universiteta Yuridicheskogo fakul'teta / pod red. A. P. Dobroklonskogo [Proceedings of the Imperial Novoros¬siysk University, Faculty of Law; ed. by A. P. Do¬b-roklonskiy]. Odessa, 1912. Issue 9. 322 p.]. (In Russ.).
39. Rheinisches Museum für Jurisprudenz. Hrsg. von J(ohann) Ch(ristian Hasse). Vol. 2. 1828. 475 p. Available at: http://books.google. com/books?id=wV9AAAAAcAAJ&hl=&source=gbs_api (accessed 29.01.2020). (In Germ.).
40. Testamentkosten, Notar, Gericht. Available at: http://www.n-heydorn.de/testament-notar-rechner.html (accessed 21.01.2020). (In Germ.).
41. Schlitt G. Klassische Testamentsklauseln. Berlin: Richard Boorberg Verlag, 2003. 116 p. (In Germ.).
42. Was Steht in Einem Erbvertrag? Available at: https://www.sueddeutsche.de/geld/alter¬na¬tive-zum-testament-was-steht-in-einem-erbvertrag-1.2399299 (accessed 21.12.2019). (In Germ.).
43. What is Estate Planning? Available at: https://www.estateplanning.com/What-is-Estate-Planning/ (accessed 03.02.2020). (In Eng.)
Received: 05.02.2020
Financing: ---

 


     

      

 
The Perm State University
614990, Perm, street Bukireva, 15
+7 (342) 2 396 275
vesturn@yandex.ru
ISSN 1995-4190 ISSN (eng.) 2618-8104
ISSN (online) 2658-7106
DOI 10.17072/1995-4190
(с) Editorial board, 2010
The magazine is registered in Federal Agency of supervision in sphere of communication and mass communications.
The certificate on registration of mass media ПИ № ФС77-33087 from September, 5th, 2008
The certificate on reregistration of mass media ПИ № ФС77-53189 from Marth, 14th, 2013

The magazine is included in List ВАК and in the Russian index of scientific citing

The founder & Publisher: the State educational institution of the higher training
“The Perm State University”.
Publishing 4 times a year