Issue 4 (22) 2013

Lutsenko_Declaring the Land Selling Public Auction Invalid Ъ and the Consequences of its Nullity

Declaring the Land Selling Public Auction Invalid and the Consequences of its Nullity

D.S. Lutsenko

Institute of Legislative forecasting and legal expertise
8 of., 4, Patorzhinskogo st., Kyiv, Ukraine, 01084
E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Abstract: We investigate the legislative regulation of legal relations in the sphere of invalidation of transactions, including the recognition of public bidding for the implementation of land highlights the main reason the auction is invalid, and discusses their implications and how to use them as a result of the recognition of trading (auction) invalid. Held in the characterization of the existing approaches to the doctrine of legislative regulation of legal relations in the sphere of invalidation of transactions, including the recognition of public auctions for the sale of land. The article examines the existing scientific approaches concerning these issues, justified the author's own position, makes proposals and conclusions aimed at improving the doctrine of law and legislation.

In the domestic judicial practice, there is a wide range of controversial provisions affecting the enforcement of the rules of special legislation. The auction is invalid shall entail the invalidity of the contract concluded on trades. The requirements for the bidding procedures contained in the numerous normative – legal acts governing the organization and conduct of public bidding, differ depending on the type of trading.

The article stresses that scientific approaches to the invalidation of transactions, unfortunately, were not reflected in the current regulatory control of relations arising in connection with the sale of property by public auction (auction). In this regard, the purpose of scientific publication is in the comprehensive study of legislative regulation of legal relations in the sphere of invalidation of transactions, including the recognition of public bidding for the implementation of the land.

Keywords: land; public auction (auction); the invalidity of the transaction; the use of effects; bidder; seller; bona fide purchaser; a specialized organization; the protocol of trading

Bibliograficheskij spisok

1. Vinaver A.V. Na grani ugolovnoj i grazhdanskoj nepravdy. (Materialy k predstojashhemu peresmotru GK RSFSR) // Antologija Ural. civilistiki. 1925–1989: sb. st. M.: Statut, 2001. S. 80–85.

2. Dolgopolova L.N. Zakljuchenie dogovorov na torgah: dis. … kand. jurid. nauk. Kiev, 2013. 131 s.

3. processual'nyj kodeks Ukrainy ot 18 marta 2004 g. URL: http://zakon0.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1618-15 (data obrashhenija: 20.05.2013).

4. Kievskogo apelljacionnogo hozjajstvennogo suda ot 27 janv. 2010 g. po delu №6/11 // Edinyj gos. reestr sud. reshenij Ukrainy. URL: http://www/reyestr/ court.gov.ua (data obrashhenija: 20.05.2013).

5. VHSU ot 27 marta 2010 g. po delu №48/210(05-548/347) // Edinyj gos. reestr sudeb. reshenij Ukrainy. URL: http://www/reyestr/court.gov.ua (data obrashhenija: 20.05.2013).

6. Vysshego hozjajstvennogo suda ot 22 marta 2006 g. po delu №18-91 / Edinyj gos. reestr sudeb. reshenij Ukrainy. URL: http://www/reyestr/court.gov.ua (data obrashhenija: 20.05.2013).

7. Hozjajstvennogo suda g. Kieva ot 15 dek. 2006 g. po delu №4076-99. / Edinyj gos. reestr sud. reshenij Ukrainy. URL: http://www/reyestr/court.gov.ua (data obrashhenija: 20.05.2013).

8. Vasilevskaja L.Ju. Uchenie o veshhnyh pravah po germanskomu pravu. M.: Statut, 2004. 450 s.