DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2015-2-133-141

DELIBERATE NON-PERFORMANCE OF CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS AS AN INDICIUM OF FRAUD PROVIDED FOR BY ARTICLE 159.4
OF THE CRIMINAL CODE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

А.N. Lebedev

Perm State University

15, Bukireva st., Perm, 614990

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Yu.А. Didenko

Main Investigative Directorate for the Perm Region

Ministry of the Interior of the Russian Federation

74, Komsomolsky av, Perm, 614000

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Introduction: the article considers the new types of fraud introduced into the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in 2012. The authors point out a number of problems associated with the differentiation among the new articles, as well as between these articles and Article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation and torts. They also study the issues of the qualification of fraud related with deliberate non-performance of contractual obligations. Purpose: to determine the most typical situations in which the non-performance of contractual obligations shall be qualified under Article 159.4 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, taking into account modern court and investigative practice, and also establish the content of the new indicium of fraud – deliberate non-performance of contractual obligations. Methods: the methodological framework of the paper is based on a set of methods of scientific cognition: general scientific methods (analysis and synthesis, dialectics) and methods specific to legal science (comparative legal and technical methods). Results: the paper considers the instances of non-performance of obligations indicating presence/absence of deliberate behaviour that are common in the law enforcement practice. In addition, the authors define the concept of “deliberate non-performance of contractual obligations” as a constituent element of the offence provided for by Article 159.4 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation; compare the concepts of “non-performance of duties” and “non-performance of obligations”; determine the relationship between the non-performance of obligations under a civil transaction and the criminal offence; distinguish between a person’s criminal and non-criminal behaviour. Conclusions: non-performance of obligations can be presented in a variety of ways: in proportion to the scope of fulfilled/non-fulfilled obligations, to the term of the performance of obligations, to the beginning and termination of the non-performance of obligations, etc. The deliberate non-performance of contractual obligations as a constituent element of the offence provided for by Article 159.4 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation is the action (inaction) of parties that contradict the provisions of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation on the performance of obligations of the certain type and exclude the possibility to fulfil the liabilities specified in the contract, partially or in full, committed with intent which arose either before the execution of the contract or during its execution

Keywords: offences against property; fraud; types of fraud;
deliberate non-performance of contractual obligations in criminal law

References

1. Aleksandrova I.A. Zakonodatel'stvo o moshennichestve v svete raz''yasneniy prezidiuma Verkhovnogo Suda RF. Noveyshaya praktika primeneniya st. 159, 159.1–159.6 UK RF [Fraud Legislation in Terms of Explanations of the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. The Latest Application Practice for Art. 159, Art. 159.1-159.6 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation] // Ros. sledovatel' – The Russian Investigator. 2014. № 4. Pp. 32–35. (In Russ).
2. Grazhdanskiy kodeks Rossiyskoy Fede-ratsii. Chast' pervaya ot 30 noyab. 1994 g. № 51-FZ (red. ot 02.03.2015) [The Civil Code of the Russian Federation (part 1) of 30.11.1994 № 51-FZ] // Ros. gazeta – The Russian Gazette. 1994. 8 dek. (In Russ).
3. Grazhdanskiy kodeks Rossiyskoy Fede-ratsii. Chast' vtoraya ot 26 yanv. 1996 g. № 14-FZ (red. ot 02.03.2015) [The Civil Code of the Russian Federation (part 2) of 26.01.1996] // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federatsii – Collected Legislation of the Russian Federation. 1996. № 5. Art. 410. (In Russ).
4. Esakov G. Moshennichestvo v sfere pred-prinimatel'skoy deyatel'nosti (st. 159.4 UK RF): problemy primene-niya normy [Fraud in the Field of Entrepreneurial Activity (Art. 159.4 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation): The Problems of the Norm Application] // Ugolovnoe pravo– Criminal Law. 2014. № 3. Pp. 40–44. (In Russ).
5. Mayorova E.I. Nekotorye problemy so-vershenstvovaniya ugolovnogo zakonoda-tel'stva Rossii na sovremennom etape[Some Problems of the Russian Criminal Legislation Improvement at the Present Stage] // Ros. sledovatel' – The Russian Investigator. 2014. № 1. Pp. 27–31. (In Russ).
6. O sudebnoy praktike po delam o moshen-nichestve, prisvoenii i rastrate: posta-novlenie Plenuma Verkhov. Suda RF ot 27 dek. 2007 g. № 51 [On the Judicial Practice of Fraud, Misappropriation and Defalcation Cases: Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 27 December, 2007 № 51] // Ros. Gazeta– The Russian Gazette. 2008. 12 yanv. (In Russ).
7. Obzor sudebnoy praktiki po primene-niyu Federal'nogo zakona ot 29 noyabrya 2012 g. № 207-FZ «O vnesenii izmene-niy v UK RF i otdel'nye zakonodatel'-nye akty Rossiyskoy Federatsii» i po-stanovleniya Gosudarstvennoy Dumy Federal'nogo Sobraniya RF ot 2 iyulya 2013 g. № 2559-6 «Ob ob''yavlenii amni-stii» [Review of the Сourt Practice in Application of the Federal Law of 29 November, 2012 № 207-FZ «On the Introduction of Amendments to the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation and Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation» and Resolution of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation of 2 July, 2013 № 2559-6 GD «On the Announcement of Amnesty»]. URL: http://www.vsrf.ru/Show_pdf.php?Id =8992 (data obrashcheniya: 11.12.2014). (In Russ).
8. Ozhegov S.I. Slovar' russkogo yazyka: okolo 57000 slov [The Russian Language Dictionary: about 57000 words] / pod red. N.Yu. Shvedovoy. Moscow: Rus. yazyk, 1989. 750 p. (In Russ).
9. Otchet o chisle osuzhdennykh po vsem so-stavam prestupleniy ugolovnogo kodek-sa Rossiyskoy Federatsii za 12 mesyatsev 2013 g. [Report on the Number of the Convicted under All Components of Crime of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation for 12 months of 2013]. URL: http://www.cdep.ru/index.php?id=79&item=2362 (data obrashcheniya: 08.08.2014). (In Russ).
10. Otchet o chisle osuzhdennykh po vsem so-stavam prestupleniy ugolovnogo kodek-sa Rossiyskoy Federatsii za pervoe po-lugodie 2014 g. [Report on the Number of the Convicted under All Components of Crime of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation for the First 6 months of 2014]. URL: http://www.cdep.ru/index.php?id=79&item=586 (data ob-rashcheniya: 13.02.2014). (In Russ).
11. Otchet Permskogo kraevogo suda o chis-le privlechennykh k ugolovnoy otvet-stvennosti i vidakh ugolovnogo nakaza-niya (forma № 10.1) za 2013 god [Report of the Perm Territorial Court on the Number of Persons Held Criminally Liable and Types of Criminal Penalty (Form No. 10.1) for 2013]. URL: http://oblsud.perm.sudrf.ru/modules.php? name=docum_sud&rid=103 (data obra-shcheniya: 10.02.2015). (In Russ).
12. Otchet Permskogo kraevogo suda o chis-le privlechennykh k ugolovnoy otvet-stvennosti i vidakh ugolovnogo nakaza-niya (forma № 10.1) za pervoe polugodie 2014 goda [Report of the Perm Territorial Court on the Number of Persons Held Criminally Liable and Types of Criminal Penalty (form No. 10.1) for the First 6 months of 2014]. URL: http://oblsud.perm.sudrf.ru/modules.php? name=docum_sud&rid= 104 (data obrashcheniya: 11.02.2015). In Russ).
13. Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 11 dek. 2014 g. № 32-P «Po delu o proverki konstitutsionnosti polozheniy stat'i 159.4 Ugolovnogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii v svyazi s zaprosom Salekhardskogo gorodskogo suda Yamalo-Nenetskogo avtonomnogo okruga» [Resolution of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of 11 December, 2014 № 32-P «Concerning the Case about Verification of Constitutionality of the Provisions of Art. 159.4 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation to the Request of the Salekhard Municipal Court of the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous District»] // Ros. gazeta – The Russian Gazette. 2014. 24 dek. (In Russ).
14. Ugolovnyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federa-tsii ot 13 iyunya 1996 g. № 63-FZ (v red. ot 30.03.2015) [The Criminal Code of the Russian Federation of June 13, 1996 № 63-FZ] // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federatsii– Collected Legislation of the Russian Federation. 1996. № 25. Art. 2954. (In Russ).
15. Tsenova T.L. O rassledovanii moshenni-chestv, svyazannykh s nevypolneniem vzya-tykh obyazatel'stv [On the Investigation of Frauds Associated with the Default of Obligations Imposed] // Yurist – The Lawyer. 2010. № 9. Pp. 56–60. (In Russ).