Issue 1 (19) 2013

Vinichenko_NEIGHBOR LAW AND PROPERTY LAW: Interrelation Issue (historic-legal research)

NEIGHBOR LAW AND PROPERTY LAW:
Interrelation Issue (historic-legal research)

Yu.V. Vinichenko

Baikal State University of Economics and Law

11, Lenin str., Irkutsk, 664003

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Article is devoted to the historic-legal analysis of the norms of the socalled neighbor rights, which are one of the potential novels of the Russian civil law and which formulated in the draft federal law on amendments to the Civil Code of the Russian Federation as a restriction of the right of property in favor of neighbors. Thinking that the result of this design the norms of the neighbor law are only "logical continuation" of the institution of property law, the author consistently proves the thesis that there is no ontological connection between the neighbor law and the property law. In particular, it is noted that the origin of the Institute of property law can not speak before fixing in law the concept of "property law", and points out that in Russia it only happens at the end of XVIII century. In this case, on the basis of analysis of the sources of Russian law and the doctrine is proved that the rules relating to neighborhood relations existed in domestic law and in the periods in which the institution of private property law of land in Russia was absent (up to the XVIII century, the "Soviet" period ). As a consequence, critically evaluated of the planned fixation of the norms of the neighbor law in the RF Civil Code in the section of property law.

In addition, considered the issue of the origin norms of the neighbor law. It is noted that their appearance is the result of emergence of neighborhood relations in society that began to emerge as a result of the transition from the primitive community to the neighbor's farming community. Based on the fact that the hallmark of the neighborhood community was the presence of an individual property, it is concluded that the individualization of real estate, ie, actual assignment of property by individual members of the team should be considered the main factor responsible for the appearance of neighbor law norms. At the same time emphasizes that individualization of real estate is not the same law of private property.

 Keywords: neighborhood relations; neighbor law; property law; restrictions of property rights; the right to participate

Bibliograficheskij spisok

1. Aslanjan N.P. Osnovnye nachala rossijskogo chastnogo prava. Irkutsk, 2001. 270 s.

2. Beljaev I.D. Lekcii po istorii russkogo zakonodatel'stva. M., 1879. VIII. 728 s.

3. Vinichenko Ju.V. Istoricheskie nachala sosedskogo prava v Rossii. Irkutsk, 2012. 84 s.

4. Vladimirskij-Budanov M.F. Obzor istorii russkogo prava. M., 2005. 800 s.

5. Gornyj zakon RSFSR: vved. postanovleniem VCIK, SNK RSFSR ot 15 okt. 1928 g. // SU RSFSR. 1928. №133, st. 871.

6. Grazhdanskij kodeks RSFSR: vved. postanovleniem VCIK ot 11 nojab. 1922 g. // Izvestija VCIK. 1922. №256.

7. Gribanov V.P. Predely osushhestvlenija i zashhity grazhdanskih prav // Gribanov V.P. Osushhestvlenie i zashhita grazhdanskih prav. M., 2001. S. 19–212.

8. Grimm D. Sootnoshenie mezhdu juridicheskimi institutami i konkretnymi otnoshenijami. M., 1914. 18 s.

9. Evreinova A.M. O znachenii i predelah obychnogo prava pri razrabotke otdel'nyh institutov Grazhdanskogo Ulozhenija. SPb., 1883. 42 s.

10. Erofeev B.V. Pravovoj rezhim zemel' gorodov. M., 1976. 200 s.

11. Zemel'nyj kodeks RSFSR: prinjat postanovleniem VCIK ot 30 okt. 1922 g. // SU RSFSR. 1922. №68, st. 901.

12. Karamzin M.N. Istorija gosudarstva Rossijskogo. M., 2005. 1024 s.

13. Karcov A.S. K voprosu o pravotvorcheskoj dejatel'nosti Pravitel'stvujushhego Senata: problema «prava uchastija chastnogo» // Civilisticheskie issledovanija. Ezhegodnik grazhdanskogo prava / pod red. D.O. Tuzova, B.L. Haskel'berga. M., 2007. Vyp. 3. S. 147–172.

14. Komarov B.K. Ob ogranichenii prava sobstvennosti po GK RSFSR. Irkutsk, 1929. 48 s.

15. Minakov L.I. K voprosu o ponjatii pravil socialisticheskogo obshhezhitija // Voprosy gosudarstva i prava. Tomsk, 1968. T. 199. S. 9–14.

16. Novickij I.B. Pravo sobstvennosti. Sub#ekty, ob#ekty, soderzhashhie i zashhita prava sobstvennosti. Pravo obshhej sobstvennosti. M., 1925. 64 s.

17. Novickij I.B. Pravo sosedstva. Ramki i znachenie problemy // Pravo i zhizn'. 1924. Kn. 5–6. S. 3–12.

18. Novickij I.B. Pravo sosedstva. Obshhie predely pol'zovanija smezhnymi uchastkami // Pravo i zhizn'. 1924. Kn. 7–8. S. 10–21.

19. Novickij I.B. Stroitel'nye pravila i pravo sosedstva // Pravo i zhizn'. 1924. Kn. 10. S. 3–12.

20. O vnesenii izmenenij v chasti pervuju, vtoruju, tret'ju i chetvertuju Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj Federacii, a takzhe v otdel'nye zakonodatel'nye akty Rossijskoj Federacii: proekt Feder. zakona Ros. Federacii ot 27 apr. 2012 g. №47538-6 [Jelektronnyj resurs]. Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoj sistemy «Konsul'tantPljus».

21. O pravil'nom ispol'zovanii zhivogo i mertvogo inventarja putem trudovoj vzaimopomoshhi v celjah obrabotki i obsemenenija malomoshhnyh i krasnoarmejskih hozjajstv: instrukcija; utv. dekretom SNK RSFSR ot 17 marta 1921 g. // Izvestija VCIK. 1921. №61.

22. O privlechenii naselenija k remontu vodoprovoda, kanalizacii, gazovogo i central'nogo otoplenija v municipalizirovannyh domah: dekret SNK RSFSR ot 18 ijulja 1921 g. // Izvestija VCIK. 1921. №166.

23. O socializacii zemli: dekret VCIK ot 19 fevr. 1918 g. // Gazeta Rabochego i Krest'janskogo Pravitel'stva. 1918. 19 fevr.

24. O socialisticheskom zemleustrojstve i o merah perehoda k socialisticheskomu zemledeliju: polozhenie VCIK ot 14 fevr. 1919 g. // Izvestija VCIK. 1919. №34.

25. Pahman S.V. Obychnoe grazhdanskoe pravo v Rossii. Juridicheskie ocherki. T. 1: Sobstvennost', objazatel'stva i sredstva sudebnogo ohranenija. SPb., 1877. 447 s.

26. Porotikova O.A. Problema zloupotreblenija sub#ektivnym grazhdanskim pravom. M., 2007. 256 s.

27. Rossijskoe zakonodatel'stvo X–XX vekov: v 9 t. T. 1: Zakonodatel'stvo Drevnej Rusi. M., 1984. 432 s.

28. Rossijskoe zakonodatel'stvo X–XX vekov: v 9 t. T. 2: Zakonodatel'stvo perioda obrazovanija i ukreplenija Russkogo centralizovannogo gosudarstva. M., 1985. 520 s.

29. Rossijskoe zakonodatel'stvo X–XX vekov: v 9 t. T. 3: Akty Zemskih soborov. M., 1985. 512 s.

30. Svod zakonov Rossijskoj imperii. Polnyj tekst vseh 16 tomov, soglasovannyj s poslednimi prodolzhenijami, izdannymi v porjadke st. 87 zakonov osnovnyh, i pozdnejshimi uzakonenijami: neofic. izd. / sost. N.P. Balkanov, S.S. Vojt, V. Gercenberg; pod red. I.D. Morduhaj-Boltovskogo. SPb., 1912. T. XII [Jelektronnyj resurs]. Dostup iz sprav.-pravovoj sistemy «Konsul'tantPljus».

31. Semenov Ju.I. Pervobytnaja kommuna i sosedskaja krest'janskaja obshhina // Stanovlenie klassov i gosudarstva: sb. statej. M., 1976. S. 7–86.

32. Sovetskaja istoricheskaja jenciklopedija / gl. red. E.M. Zhukov. M., 1967. T. 10. 1040 stb.

33. Shershenevich G.F. Kurs grazhdanskogo prava. Tula, 2001. 720 s.