|

Вестник Пермского университета. Юридические науки

Научный юридический журнал, индексируемый в Web of Science

I. THEORETICAL AND HISTORICAL LAW SCIENCES

Ghambaryan A.S., Dallakyan L.G. The Theoretical and Legal Foundations of Statutory Lists: From the Concept to Practical Application

📑Download article

For citation:

Ghambaryan A. S., Dallakyan L. G. Teoreko -pravov osn ye ovy zakonodatel’nykh perechney: ot kontseptsii k prakke primeneniya [The Theore;cal and Legal Founda;ons of Statutory Lists: From the Concept to Prac;cal Applica;on]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Scie es. nc 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 326–350. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-326-350.

The Theoretical and Legal Foundations of Statutory Lists:
From the Concept to Practical Application

S. Ghambaryan
Russian-Armenian (Slavonic) University
E-mail: artur.ghambaryan@gmail.com

L. G. Dallakyan
Russian-Armenian (Slavonic) University
E-mail: Lilit.dallakyan@rau.am

Received 30 Apr 2025

Introduction: the study analyzes and develops the concept of closed (numerus clausus) and open
(numerus apertus) statutory lists, which are an important tool of legislave technique. Each type of lists is
characterized by a special structure and special linguisc means that explicitly or implicitly indicate the
cl d ose or open nature of a list. Purpose: the arcle aims to analyze the types of statutory lists and provide
a classificaon thereof, as well as to study judicial pracce in their applicaon. This is essen al since a
wrong choice of the type of list, errors in the technique of its formulaon, or incorrect classificaon of a
list by a law enforcer entails serious negave consequences for legal regulaon. Results: the authors have
developed a classification of closed lists according to their locaon in the elements of the structure of legal
norms and to the completeness of the enumeraon (complete and incomplete closed lists) as well as a
classificaon of open lists according to various methods of enumerang their elements and the use of
specifying uage lang tools (simple lists and lists of a concrezing nature). In addion, through an analysis
of legislaon and judicial pracce, the authors have derived the concept of a simulacrum of a closed list,
which creates the illusion of an exhausve list, and also have elucidated the relaonship between ‘numerus
cl s’ ause and the maxim ‘expressio unius’, which is a rule of interpretaon widely used in foreign judicial
pracce. Conclusions: the diff on of erena open and closed lists and their subtypes, the disncon made
between open lists and incomplete closed lists, and the idenficaon of simulacra of closed lists, all contribute to a deeper understanding of their funconal role in legal regulaon. A crical analysis of judicial
prac inclu t t ce, ding he study of he applicaon of ‘expressio unius’, the study of the ‘opening’ by courts of
cl d st ose atutory lists through the development of law, the idenficaon of different approaches o f rts cou
to e th interpretaon and correcon of lists, indicates the complexity and mulfaceted nature of the category of ‘sta ory list’ and th tut e need to systemaze special knowledge about all its aspects.

Key ds: wor ‘classifica;on of statutory lists; numerus clausus; numerus apertus; expressio unius;
devel t opmen of law contra legem; simulacrum of a closed statutory list; incomplete closed list;
open st y atutor list with concre;zing language means applied

Kleandrov M.I., Vinogradova E.V. Evolution of the Status of Russian Judges: A Historiographic Perspective

📑Download article

For citation:

Kleandrov M. I., Vinogradova E. V. Evolyutsiya statusa rossiyskikh sudey: istoriograficheskiy rakurs [Evolution of the Status of Russian Judges: A Historiographic Perspective]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 351–371. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-351-371.

 

EVOLUTION OF THE STATUS OF RUSSIAN JUDGES: A HISTORIOGRAPHIC PERSPECTIVE

The study was carried out as part of the scientific project ‘Creating a Russian historiographic model of political-legal knowledge and its application when developing means of countering ideological distortions of Russia’s civilizational development’, financially supported by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation (Agreement No. 075-15-2024-639 of July 12, 2024)

M.I. Kleandrov

Institute of State and Law

of the Russian Academy of Sciences

E-mail: mklean@ksrf.ru

E.V. Vinogradova

Institute of State and Law

of the Russian Academy of Sciences

E-mail: evsfrf@gmail.com

 

Received 05 Sep 2025

 

Introduction: research into the evolution of the status of judges, conducted through the prism of a retrospective analysis of domestic sources, allows us to form a holistic picture. In the format of historiographic approaches, the study shows contextual influence of the past on the current state, determining the prospects for further development of the concept of the rights and responsibilities of persons conducting legal proceedings in Russia. The paper explores the manifestations of various forms of legal proceedings in Ancient Rus’, in autocratic Russia, approaches adopted in the Soviet and modern periods. The purpose of the study is to develop systemic approaches to the requirements for persons administering justice. The use of formal-legal, historiographic, comparative-legal, historical-legal, and other scientific methods allowed us to come to conclusions that substantiate the following results. The foundation of Russian justice is the assertion that the status of a judge is a combination of his rights, duties, and responsibilities, with only legal component of the status considered here, that is, without taking into account (with necessary exceptions) such components as moral, ethical, psychological, physiological, etc. An analysis of the essential characteristics of judges reveals features that allow integrating them into the concepts of modern justice. Conclusions: based on the analysis of the status of judges, the study has revealed contextual determinacy of the concept of the rights and responsibilities of persons ensuring the implementation of domestic political and legal values when administering justice. This contributes to the creation of a domestic (Russian) historiographic model of political and legal knowledge, the application of which can be considered an important element of the system of preventive mechanisms formed to counteract distortions of Russia’s role in civilizational development.

 

Keywords: court; judge; status; regulation; evolution; rights; duties; responsibility; improvement

Trikoz E.N. Roman Legal Expansion in Early Britain: Attempt at Romanization of Local Law

📑Download article

For citation:

Trikoz E. N. Rimskoye pravovoye rasshireniye v ranney Britanii: popytka romanizatsii mestnogo prava [Roman Legal Expansion in Early Britain: Attempt at Romanization of Local Law]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 372–388. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-372-388.

 

ROMAN LEGAL EXPANSION IN EARLY BRITAIN: ATTEMPT AT ROMANIZATION OF LOCAL LAW

E.N. Trikoz

MGIMO University

Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia named after Patrice Lumumba

E-mail: alena_trikoz@mail.ru

 

Received 07 May 2025

 

Introduction: in the literature on the early history of Anglo-Saxon law (pre-common law), there is a noticeable gap in the study of the emergence of the common legal order in the Roman province of Britain (1st–early 5th centuries) and in the typological assessment of this mixed legal environment. Purpose and objectives: the study aims to analyze the attempt to adapt the local law of the ancient Britons to the legal policy of the Roman Empire. The objectives are to trace the penetration of the Roman technique of revision and regulation of the Romano-Celtic vulgarized law, to conduct a partial reconstruction of the ethno-legal identity of the urban population. Methods and materials: the research materials are sources of legal Romanism and of the narrative tradition of ancient and early medieval Britain, as well as a set of various material sources, including Roman inscriptions of Britain. The historiographic concept of ‘provincial Romanization’ and the related historical and cultural approach are used to trace the continuity of the Roman legal order in the Briton-Roman cities, the relationship between the legal policy of the British elites and the processes of urbanization and adaptation of Roman law to the local legal order. The study employed dialectical, culturological, general historical, sociological, formally dogmatic methodological approaches. Results and discussion: the research has revealed the process of fragmentary mixing of the customary Briton-Celtic law and communal principles of the island Britons with the legal system of the Roman metropolis, an alien system of the higher order. In the course of the socio-political and cultural-religious transformation in the Roman province of Britain, there occurred hybridization of the local legal order. Thus, it is possible to apply the concept of legal acculturation, this meaning gradual Romanization of Old English law during the long-term colonization of the island. Nevertheless, legal and political Romanization did not lead to the complete absorption or disappearance of all aspects of the indigenous Briton-Celtic political and legal culture.

 

Keywords: Britain; Roman province; Romanization; Briton-Celtic law; Roman law; pre-classical common law; legal acculturation; systematization of law; revision and adaptation of law

II. PUBLIC LAW (STATE-LEGAL) SCIENCES

Grishin D.A. Administrative-Law Regulation: The Subject, Method, System

📑Download article

For citation:

Grishin D. A. Administrativno-pravovoe regulirovanie: predmet, metod, sistema [Administrative-Law Regulation: The Subject, Method, System]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 389–408. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-389-408.

 

ADMINISTRATIVE-LAW REGULATION: THE SUBJECT, METHOD, SYSTEM

 

The study was conducted within the framework of the scientific school ‘Organization and administrative-law foundations of public administration in the penal system’, functioning on the basis of the Academy of the FPS of Russia (Ryazan); https://apu.fsin.gov.ru/area/scientific_activities/nsch.php

D.A. Grishin

The Academy of the FPS of Russia

E-mail: dagr1979@rambler.ru

 

Received 07 May 2025

 

Introduction: the article explores doctrinal problems associated with defining the subject of administrative-law regulation and identifying the main constitutional-law trends that influence the subject and system of modern administrative law. Purpose: to form an idea of the subject and method of administrative (administrative-procedural) law, to determine the place of these branches in the system of public law, to systematize the intra-branch structure of the sub-branches and institutions. Methods: systemic-structural method, used in forming an idea of the system of legal impact; methods of analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction, used in formulating the author’s definitions; comparative-legal method, used to compare domestic (Russian) and foreign types of administrative-law regulation; historical-legal method, employed to consider the evolution of Russian and foreign legislation regulating administrative relations. Results: the study has found two interrelated categories – the ‘subject’ and ‘method of legal regulation’ – to be the criteria for dividing the le-gal system into branches, also serving as means of intra-branch structuring of sub-branches and institutions. The subject is a specific sphere of social relations, separate from others. The method of legal regulation is a single structured system of legal impact, represented by a unique (for each branch of law) set of combinations of primary methods of legal impact (first structural level), means of legal impact (second level), and techniques of legal impact (third level). Conclusions: taking into account the abovenamed criteria, it is pro-posed to distinguish the following branches within the system of public law: administrative law, administrative-procedural law, administrative-tort law, and judicial administrative-procedural law (administrative jus-tice).

 

Keywords: administrative-law regulation; administrative legal relations; system of administrative law; subject and method of legal regulation.

Diskin E.I. Conceptual Foundations and Legal Regulation of Countering Disinformation: A Comparative Analysis Through the Lens of Interdisciplinarity

📑Download article

For citation:

Diskin E. I. Kontseptual’nye osnovy i pravovoe regulirovanie protivodeystviya dezinformatsii: sravnitel’nyy analiz cherez prizmu mezhdistsiplinarnosti [Conceptual Foundations and Legal Regulation of Countering Disinformation: A Comparative Analysis Through the Lens of Interdisciplinarity]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 409–429. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-409-429.

 

CONCEPTUAL FOUNDATIONS AND LEGAL REGULATION

OF COUNTERING DISINFORMATION:

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS THROUGH THE LENS OF INTERDISCIPLINARITY

 

The article was prepared within the framework of the Fundamental Research Program of the National Research University

‘Higher School of Economics’ (HSE University)

 E.I. Diskin

National Research University ‘Higher School of Economics’

(HSE University)

E-mail: ediskin@hse.ru

 

Received 07 May 2025

 

Introduction: disinformation is currently among the most complex challenges for legal regulation. Different legal systems respond differently to such challenges under conditions of geopolitical tension. The phenomenon of disinformation is analyzed by representatives from various scientific fields, but it has not been sufficiently explored from a legal perspective, and it has yet to find its place in domestic (Russian) legislation. At the same time, in foreign countries the term ‘disinformation’ has firmly established itself in legislation and is actively researched by jurists as well as representatives from other sciences. Particular importance is placed on countering disinformation, the relevant legal practices are being formed, especially these concerning countermeasures against disinformation in cyberspace. Purpose: the study aims to provide a comparative analysis of the legislation of the EU, the USA, and Russia in the field of combating disinformation, define the legal essence of disinformation, and identify the shortcomings of Russian legislation in this area. Methods: the comparative-legal method, the method of juridical hermeneutics, the historical-legal method, and a systematic approach are used to study the phenomenon of disinformation as a concept that may find reflection in various areas of Russian law – criminal, administrative, and informational law. Results: the au-thor has analyzed the legislation of the EU, the USA, and Russia, examined how legal sciences in Russia and abroad define disinformation, what approaches to countering disinformation are proposed by legal scholars, and compared these findings with conclusions drawn by specialists from other fields. Conclusions: currently Russian legislation is not fully adequate to deal with the broad spectrum of challenges associated with the spread of disinformation. In this regard, EU legislation is significantly more effective in addressing tasks related to combating disinformation through the application of various regulatory methods, detailed formulation of norms and definitions. Foreign legislation in this sphere is largely aimed at countering Russian interests, which poses an independent challenge to the sovereignty of the Russian Federation.

 

Keywords: disinformation; internet platforms; moderation; infodemic; fake news; digital technologies; Digital Code

III. CRIMINAL LAW SCIENCES

Chernyshev D.B. The Holy Inquisition in the History of the Formation of Modern Criminal Procedure

📑Download article

For citation:

Chernyshev D. B. «Svyataya inkvizitsiya» v istorii formirovaniya sovremennogo ugolovnogo protsessa [The Holy Inquisi-tion in the History of the Formation of Modern Criminal Procedure]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 430–444. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-430-444.

 

ТHE HOLY INQUISITION IN THE HISTORY OF THE FORMATION

OF MODERN CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

D.B. Chernyshev

Ural Law Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation

E-mail: SledstvieNT404@mail.ru

 

Received 10 Apr 2025

 

Introduction.  The article provides a comparative analysis of the procedure in trials against heretics, witches, and sorcerers as presented in the 15th-century treatise Malleus Maleficārum (Hammer of Witches) and modern Russian legislation on criminal procedure. Without assessing the very fact of prosecution on religious grounds, the author of the paper traces the similarities in the logic of evidence collection, interpretation, and evaluation by comparing the methods used by medieval and modern investigators. The institute of investigative torture, used by the Inquisition to extract confessions, is described separately. Purpose: this study aims to trace the continuity between modern criminal proceedings as well as the tactics and method-ology of criminalistics and the Inquisition’s procedures, applied in the case of crimes against faith. Methods: general scientific methods of analysis, generalization, analogy, dialectics; special scientific methods of comparative legal analysis, content analysis. Results: an analysis comparing the procedure for the conduct of in-vestigations and witch trials described in the Malleus Maleficārum with modern criminal procedural legislation showed the following common features of these: the general logical line of investigators’ activities aimed at collecting evidence of guilt and innocence; focus on uncovering the truth related to clarifying the objective circumstances of a crime. Conclusions: many provisions of the treatise Malleus Maleficārum have been preserved in modern criminal proceedings with minor changes. At the same time, some features of the Inquisition contradicted modern principles such as the independence of judges, respect for the honor and dignity of the individual, personal integrity, the presumption of innocence, and the right to appeal against procedural actions and decisions. Principles such as adversariality and the right of the accused to a defense, although present, were expressed in a much more limited form. The general accusatory orientation of the Inquisition also distances it from modernity. However, from an external, procedural point of view, it had a goal similar to that of modern proceedings – the establishment of the truth, the protection of the innocent from false accusations.

 

Keywords: Malleus Maleficārum; Inquisition; criminal procedure; heresy; crime against faith

III. INTERNATIONAL LAW SCIENCES

Malichenko V.S. The Role of Sanctions in Violating International Legal Guarantees of Health Protection

📑Download article

For citation:

Malichenko V. S. Rol’ sanktsiy v ogranichenii obespecheniya mezhdunarodno-pravovykh garantiy okhrany zdorov’ya cheloveka [The Role of Sanctions in Violating International Legal Guarantees of Health Protection]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 445–460. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-445-460.

 

THE ROLE OF SANCTIONS IN VIOLATING

INTERNATIONAL LEGAL GUARANTEES OF HEALTH PROTECTION

V.S. Malichenko

Institute of Legislation and Comparative Law under the Government of the Russian Federation

E-mail: vlad.malichenko@gmail.com

 

Received 30 Apr 2025

 

Introduction: sanctions and unilateral restrictive measures have a significant impact on the pace of technological development, availability of medicines and medical devices, and implementation of social guarantees, thus leading to a humanitarian catastrophe in each specific state, which can undoubtedly be assessed as a violation of fundamental human rights formulated in the UDHR and ICESCR. The purpose of the study is to systematize doctrinal views and legal mechanisms intended to counteract the socio-economic consequences of sanctions and unilateral restrictive measures. The research methods employed in the research include a set of general scientific methods (systemic method, modeling, formal-logical method) and specific scientific methods (inter-branch, historical-legal, comparative-legal, formal-legal methods). Results: in the foreign doctrine of international law, the concepts of sanctions and unilateral restrictive measures have been equated, which legitimizes the policy of foreign states regarding uncontrolled application of those. The international community has consistently attempted to develop legal mechanisms that would allow certain categories of goods and services to be exempted from restrictions imposed. However, the threat of ‘secondary sanctions’ against legal entities interacting with states subject to sanctions or unilateral restrictive measures, which entails potential economic losses, prevents these mechanisms from being used to the fullest extent. Conclusions: healthcare technologies, as well as the means of their production and development, should be exempted from the influence of sanctions or unilateral restrictive measures. A similar approach should be applied to technologies used in the production of medicines and medical devices, many of which are defined as dual-use technologies. In the context of the failure of international law to counter the socio-economic consequences of sanctions and unilateral restrictive measures at the domestic level, there are being developed special legal mechanisms aimed at achieving technological sovereignty, protecting the well-being of the population, and ensuring human security.

 

Keywords: sanctions; secondary sanctions; right to health; right to benefit from scientific progress; social protection; provision of medicines; unilateral restrictive measures; humanitarian exceptions

Puzyreva Yu.V. International Legal Regulation of the Military-Force Approach to the Fight Against Terrorism at the Universal and Regional Levels (taking the examples of the UN and the CIS)

📑Download article

For citation:

Puzyreva Yu. V. Mezhdunarodno-pravovoe regulirovanie voenno-silovogo podkhoda k bor’be s terrorizmom na univer-sal’nom i regional’nom urovne (na primere OON i SNG) [International Legal Regulation of the Military-Force Approach to the Fight Against Terrorism at the Universal and Regional Levels (taking the examples of the UN and the CIS)]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 461–481. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-461-481.

 

INTERNATIONAL LEGAL REGULATION OF THE MILITARY-FORCE APPROACH TO THE FIGHT AGAINST TERRORISM AT THE UNIVERSAL AND REGIONAL LEVELS (TAKING THE EXAMPLES OF THE UN AND THE CIS)

Yu. V. Puzyreva

Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation named after V. Y. Kikot

E-mail: yuliya_dugina@mail.ru

 

Received 07 May 2025

 

Introduction: international terrorism is a modern global threat that requires joint efforts of states to counter it, these undertaken within the framework of multi-aspect anti-terrorist cooperation, including law enforcement and military-force components. At the universal level, under the auspices of the United Nations (UN), there is no common understanding regarding the establishment of a legal regime governing the use of military forces and means by states to respond to terrorist threats. As a result, there has been gradually formed the so-called political regime of the ‘war on terrorism’. Meanwhile, at the regional level, under the auspices of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), there has been formalized international legal regulation that governs military-force counteraction to terrorist threats through the legitimate use of military forces and means within the framework of a special legal regime of the ‘counter-terrorism operation’ (hereinafter referred to as the CTO), which has significant differences from the traditional regime of the use of armed forces and the ‘war on terrorism’. Рurpose: to identify and compare approaches of states at the universal (UN) and regional (CIS) levels to the international legal regulation of military-force counteraction to terrorism; to substantiate the need to develop international legal foundations for the CTO regime at the universal level. Methods: general scientific and specific scientific methods. Results: gaps in the regulation of the CTO regime at the universal level were identified; tested models of state behavior in the so-called ‘war on terrorism’ were studied, with problems revealed in applying the provisions of international humanitarian and anti-terrorist law. The international legal and organizational foundations for regulating the CTO regime with-in the CIS were studied; prospects for the development of the concept of military-force counteraction to terrorism were formulated. Conclusions: in modern realities, the military-force approach of states to the fight against terrorism is most effectively implemented within the framework of comprehensive and multicomponent activities under the legal regime of the CTO, which allows combining law enforcement and military tasks facing the states. The CTO regime has been tested and has proven its effectiveness within the frame-work of anti-terrorist cooperation of the CIS member states.

 

Keywords: terrorism; military-force fight against terrorism; war on terrorism; illegal combatants; counter-terrorism operation; military-police operation; United Nations; Commonwealth of Independent States

 

 

Gulyamov S.S. Mechanisms for Building Trust in AI-Assisted Justice Systems Through Cognitive, Emotional and Socio-Psychological Factors

📑Download article

For citation:

Gulyamov S. S. Mechanisms for Building Trust in AI-Assisted Justice Systems Through Cognitive, Emotional and Socio-Psychological Factors Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 3(69). Pp. 482–491. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-69-482-491.

 

MECHANISMS FOR BUILDING TRUST IN AI-ASSISTED JUSTICE SYSTEMS THROUGH COGNITIVE, EMOTIONAL AND SOCIO-PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS

S.S. Gulyamov

Tashkent State University of Law

E-mail: said.gulyamov1976@gmail.com

 

Received 07 Apr 2025

 

Introduction: artificial intelligence (AI) is progressively gaining traction within legal and judicial spheres, which necessitates a re-examination of concepts such as transparency, fairness, reliability, and legitimacy. The implementation of explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) is a key element in ensuring trust in such systems, though ‘explainability’ does not in itself guarantee that people will begin to trust these systems. Purpose: the study aims to provide a detailed analysis and systematization of available scientific information on psychological mechanisms underlying the formation of trust in explainable artificial intelligence systems ap-plied in the field of justice, with the cognitive, emotional, and socio-psychological aspects considered. Methods: the study employed methods of analysis and synthesis to explore the complex system of the formation of trust in explainable artificial intelligence in the field of justice. An analysis of a wide range of open sources, including scientific articles, legal documents and research reports, made it possible to categorize facts regarding the perception of computerized judicial decisions and the level of trust in them. Results: the research has established that trust in AI applied in the field of justice develops at the intersection of three key aspects: the understanding of the fundamentals of AI operations, emotional acceptance of the technology, and its adherence to social norms. The author explains the significance of transparency and explainability of AI decisions, of the ability of AI systems to interact with users on an emotional level, and of the role of public opinion and expert examination in trust development. The study has found correlations between perceived accuracy of AI systems and trust levels, elucidated the importance of empathetic characteristics in AI interfaces and the influence of group dynamics on trust formation. Conclusions: the findings demonstrate the need for a comprehensive approach to AI implementation in the legal sector that would consider both psychological and technological factors. The paper provides practical recommendations for increasing trust in AI in justice, including the development of training programs, standardized explainability schemes, and transparent audit mechanisms. Recommended areas of future research include studies into cross-cultural variations in attitudes to AI, long-term strategic consequences and ramifications of justice automation, and the development of methods for assessing the effectiveness of human-AI collaboration in court.

 

Keywords: artificial intelligence; justice; trust; explainability; cognitive factors; emotional perception; socio-psychological aspects