|

Вестник Пермского университета. Юридические науки

Научный юридический журнал, индексируемый в Web of Science

I. THEORETICAL AND HISTORICAL LAW SCIENCES

Pozdnyakova E.A. A Historical and Legal Analysis of the Formation and Development of the Stages of Land Planning Fees (from 1917 to the Present)

📑Download article

For citation:

Pozdnyakova E. A. Istoriko-pravovoy analiz stanovleniya i razvitiya etapov platy za zemleustroystvo (s 1917 gоda po nastoyashchee vremya) [A Historical and Legal Analysis of the Formation and Development of the Stages of Land Planning Fees (from 1917 to the Present)]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 144–165. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-144-165.

 

HISTORICAL AND LEGAL ANALYSIS OF THE FORMATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE STAGES OF LAND MANAGEMENT FEES (FROM 1917 TO THE PRESENT)

 

E.A. Pozdnyakova

National Research University Higher School of Economics

E-mail: elenaap7306@mail.ru

Received 11 Dec 2024

 

Introduction: the article is devoted to the analysis of legal regulation of land management fees for more than a century of its development, which has shown their dynamics in different time periods. Land management fees have existed throughout the entire development period of the land management institution itself. The changing political system proved only the specifics of its legal regulation. Today, in modern-day Russia, an ambiguous situation with land management fees is being observed: on the one hand, it is not mentioned in either the Land Code of the Russian Federation or in the Federal Law “On Land Management”, on the other hand, such fees exist and are charged depending on the commissioner of the work, which creates a certain deficiency in the regulation of this institution. In anticipation of the new law “On Land Management” adoption it is essential to analyze the development pattern of land management fees, in the context of its positive and negative features. Objective: on the basis of the legal regulation analysis we are to determine the necessity to regulate land management fees under the current statutory provisions. Methods: historical, logical, comparative legal, structural and functional. Results: it has been proved that the formation of land management fees has gone through three separate stages: the first stage arose before the revolution, but we have identified it as the genesis of the topic under consideration; it was also taken as a basis by the Soviet government; the second stage is framed by the historical period from 1917 through 1990, i.e. until the moment of the land reform; the third stage covers the period after the land reform and up to the present moment. Conclusions: it has been identified that there is a direct connection between the financing of land management fees from the relevant budget and the performance of the state’s public function of managing the country’s available land. The hypothesis has been substantiated that land management fees should be included as an independent component into land fees through legislative consolidation.

Key words: state, legislation, paid land management, budget, lending, plans, estimates, contractual relations, benefits, market economy, financing.

Song Lei. A Retrospective and Rethinking of Frank Goodnow’s Stay in China

📑Download article

For citation:

Song Lei. Retrospektiva i pereosmyslenie prebyvaniya Gudnau v Kitae [A Retrospective and Rethinking of Frank Good- now’s Stay in China]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 166–174. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-166-174.

 

A RETROSPECTIVE AND RETHINKING OF GOODNOW’S STAY IN CHINA

 

Song Lei

Beijing Institute of Technology

Lomonosov Moscow State University

E-mail: 759220970@qq.com

Received 28 Dec 2024

 

Introduction: in the early years of the Republic of China, significant disagreements emerged between the Republicans, led by Sun Yat-sen, and the constitutionalists, with Yuan Shikai as their leader, on critical issues such as the Qing dynasty’s abdication and the political structure that would follow the Manchu dynasty’s fall. In this politically charged environment, Goodnow, an American scholar, arrived in China at Yuan Shikai’s invitation. From a constitutional monarchy perspective, Goodnow argued that monarchy might be more suitable for China than a republic. Purpose: this stance has generally led to a negative perception of Goodnow and Yuan Shikai in China, with many viewing Goodnow as providing Yuan Shikai the theoretical foundation for proclaiming himself emperor. However, an assessment of Goodnow’s contributions should consider a broader perspective in public administration rather than focusing solely on his theoretical positions. Methods: traditional theoretical and empirical methods: analysis, synthesis, analogies; historical, legal method of interpretation. Results: given the national conditions of the time, China faced an urgent need for stable governance—specifically, an effective government capable of ensuring peace, order, and internal security. To consolidate national power and counter the fragmented situation caused by warlords dividing provinces, China required a strong central government. Conclusion: the lack of a cooperative spirit and organizational discipline among the populace, along with limited awareness of human rights and universal education, suggested that a monarchy might have been the optimal form of government for China. A monarchy could promote state integration and foster social cohesion.

Keywords: Frank Johnson Goodnow, Yuan Shikai, Sun Yat-sen, constitutional monarchy, Republic, Constitutionalism, China.

II. PUBLIC LAW (STATE-LEGAL) SCIENCES

Aristov E.V., Ponkin I.V. The Future of Welfarism and Future Welfare State in the Context of Digitalization

📑Download article

For citation:

Aristov E. V., Ponkin I. V. Budushchee sotsial’nosti gosudarstva i sotsial’nogo gosudarstva v kontekste tsifrovizatsii [The Future of Welfarism and Future Welfare State in the Context of Digitalization]. – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 175–191. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-175-191.

 

FUTURE WELFARISM AND FUTURE WELFARE STATE IN THE CONTEXT OF DIGITALIZATION

 E.V. Aristov

Perm State National Research University

Perm State Humanitarian-Pedagogical University

E-mail: welfarestate1@gmail.com

 

I.V. Ponkin

Institute of Public Administration and Management of the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration

E-mail: ponkin-iv@ranepa.ru

 

Received 02 Mar 2025

 

Introduction. The presence of norms covering the welfare state and the state’s welfarism in the Constitution of the Russian Federation and the constitutional legislation of foreign countries allows for a conclusion about the ideal trend of state policy in this area. The development of various information technologies in the modern world will certainly have an impact on all areas of government policy. Therefore, it is important to understand how this novelty will affect the concept of a welfare state and whether it needs it at all. Purpose: trying to answer the question of whether the modern welfare state needs digitalization in its various manifestations, based on the study of the welfare state evolution, various approaches to its concept, scope and content. Methods: The methodology of the research is based on the authors’ scientific and legal constitutional and legal theories of the welfare state and the state’s welfarism, the administrative and legal theory of the public administration deviance study, as well as on the basic scientific concept of forecasting the future in law and the complex scalable and multimodal tools of predictive legal analytics. Results: The researched scientific sources, materials and regulations suggest that successful development and existence of a modern welfare state is impossible without digitalization. The task of any modern welfare state is to minimize digital risks to the state welfarism. Conclusions: The research undertaken shows the impossibility of abandoning the social function of the state and its constitutional basis, the welfare state. The task of digitalization in relation to the welfare state is to offer digital solutions that reduce the risks associated with the distribution of various benefits, abuse of budgetary funds for social purposes and their misuse, and to make the state’s social policy reasonable and rational.

Keywords: state’s welfarism, welfare state, digitalization, Russia’s Constitution, poverty, indigence, blockchain

 

Kiselеv A.S. Prospects for Legal Regulation of Social Relations in Healthcare in the Conditions of Artificial Intelligence Application

📑Download article

For citation:

Kiselеv A. S. Perspektivy pravovogo regulirovaniya obshchestvennykh otnosheniy v sfere zdravookhraneniya v uslovi- yakh primeneniya iskusstvennogo intellekta [Prospects for Legal Regulation of Social Relations in Healthcare in the Conditions of Artificial Intelligence Application]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 192–214. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-192-214.

 

PROSPECTS OF LEGAL REGULATION OF PUBLIC RELATIONS IN THE SPHERE OF HEALTH CARE IN THE CONDITIONS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE APPLICATION

 

A.S. Kiselyov

Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation

E-mail: alskiselev@fa.ru

 

Received 10 Dec 2024

 

 

Introduction: the article discusses the available trends and risks of artificial intelligence applications in healthcare. Medicine is one of the main areas of application of many modern technologies. However, the application of some technological innovations is insufficiently or not regulated by law at all, the consequence of which is the emergence of organizational difficulties and also causes distrust in a large number of patients. Objective: to review the main technologies based on artificial intelligence used in healthcare, to analyze the international and domestic legislative framework regulating this sphere, to identify the most dangerous obvious and non-obvious risks of using technologies based on elements of artificial intelligence in modern medicine, to evaluate them and to propose possible ways to overcome them. Methods: the work used general scientific methods such as description, observation, analogy, comparison, induction and deduction, analysis and synthesis, as well as private-scientific methods: comparative-legal and formal-legal. Results: mechanisms for improving the quality of medical care are presented, taking into account the risks of artificial intelligence application; the development of genetic technologies threatens the constitutional right to health protection, the right to protection of personal data, the right to protection of genetic information, the right to work, the principles of non-discrimination, social equality. Currently, the collection, storage, analysis, and use of genetic information by private companies should be restricted by law. Conclusions: it is necessary to improve domestic legislation regulating the rights of individuals and citizens to dispose of their genetic information, to regulate the procedure for training doctors and other specialists providing medical care through the use of technologies based on artificial intelligence, to create new state systems for assessing the quality of medical activity. The widespread introduction of artificial intelligence into all social processes is one of the main trends of our time, so large-scale reforms of law, health care, education, and scientific activity in this regard seem inevitable.

 

Keywords: healthcare, artificial intelligence, medicine, law, risks, legal regulation, bioethics, high-tech care, ethics, medical law.

 

III. PRIVATE LAW (CIVIL) SCIENCES

Kozhokar A.P. Notarial Control over the Withdrawal of a Participant from a Limited Liability Company: Problems of Legal Regulation and Implementation

📑Download article

For citation:

Kozhokar A. P. Notarial’nyy kontrol’ za vykhodom uchastnika iz obshchestva s ogranichennoy otvetstvennost’yu: prob- lemy pravovogo regulirovaniya i realizatsii [Notarial Control over the Withdrawal of a Participant from a Limited Liability Company: Problems of Legal Regulation and Implementation]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 215–233. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025- 68-215-233.

 

NOTARIAL CONTROL OVER THE WITHDRAWAL OF A PARTICIPANT FROM A LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY: PROBLEMS OF LEGAL REGULATION AND IMPLEMENTATION

A.P. Kozhokar

Twelfth Arbitration Court of Appeal

E-mail: andrey-kojokar@yandex.ru

 

Received 05 Mar 2025

 

Introduction. The article is devoted to studying the problems of the implementation and legal regulation of notarial control over the withdrawal of a participant from a limited liability company; the control was introduced on January 1, 2016. The need for such external control was caused by numerous “seizures” of corporate governance including the highly-publicized cases. The importance of combating abuse when a participant leaves the company, on the one hand, and the need to protect the interests of the third parties, primarily the company’s counterparties and creditors, on the other hand, resulted in the introduction of notarial control in this area of public relations. The purpose of the article is to identify the main legal problems of notarial control over the withdrawal of a participant from an LLC on the basis of a participant’s membership cancellation letter and his claim for compelling the company to buy his share (in cases when the general meeting of participants decided to make a large deal or raise the authorized capital while the participant voted against such a decision or did not participate in the voting) and the proposal of ways to solve them. Methodology: during the study, a set of general scientific and special legal methods of cognition was used, the latter primarily included legal-dogmatic and hermeneutic methods were used. Results and conclusions: The conclusion was made about the necessity to standardize the procedure of the notarial control over the participant’s filing a LLC membership cancellation letter and over his claim for compelling the company to buy his share, by imposing on the notary the obligation to submit an application for making appropriate changes to the unified state register of legal entities to the registration authority in both cases, and to send the notarized letter (claim) of the participant to the company, together with a copy of the application submitted to the registration authority. The importance of introducing notarial control over the claim for compelling to buy the participant’s share was substantiated for cases where the company’s charter prohibits the alienation of a share or part of a share possessed by a company participant to third parties and when other company participants refused to buy them, or when a consent has not been obtained to sell a share or part of a share to a company participant or a third party if obtaining such a consent is provided for in the company’s charter.

Keywords: notarial control; notary’s functions; withdrawal of a participant from a limited liability company; claim for compelling the company to buy the participant’s share; membership cancellation letter.

Kokova D.A. Public-Law and Private-Law Nature of Family Legal Relations

📑Download article

For citation:

Kokova D. A. Publichno-pravovaya i chastnopravovaya priroda semeynogo pravootnosheniya [Public-Law and Private-Law Nature of Family Legal Relations]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 234–250. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-234-250.

 

PUBLIC AND PRIVATE NATURE OF FAMILY LEGAL RELATIONS

 

D.A. Kokova

Institute of Law, Economics and Finance of the Kabardino-Balkarian State University named after N.M. Berbekov, Chegem Notary District of the Kabardino-Balkarian Republic

E-mail: d.kokowa@yandex.ru

Received 22 Apr 2025

 

Introduction: legal dualism which is conditioned by the differentiation of the private and public law spheres has been given a thorough theoretical conceptualization but was never considered in the focus of family legal relations. Within the framework of this study, an attempt has been made to comprehensively study scientific theories explaining the mechanism of separation of law into private and public (theories of the legal regulation subject and theories of the legal regulation method), as well as their relationship with the material and formal criteria for dividing law into private and public. Special attention is paid to clarifying the public and private nature of family legal relations in the context of discussing the independence of family law as one of the branches of law. It is proposed to transform the question of including the family law with private or public law into solving the issue of the balance in the private and public interests correlation. The purpose of the study is to develop a scientific understanding of family legal relations through the prism of the theory of dualism of law, as well as the theory of interest having a criterion role within the framework of the proposed concept. Methods: the traditional normativism represented the ontological component of this scientific study and predetermined the algorithm of the research object cognition. In preparing for this study, the author proceeded from the idea of a universal connection between phenomena and processes, which was thoroughly substantiated within the framework of materialistic dialectics. General scientific research methods were widely used, including induction, deduction, analogy, abstraction, comparison, etc. While emphasizing the importance of private-law research methods used in the preparation of this study, the author shall note the following: the actual picture of public-law and private-law regulation of family relations was outlined using the dogmatic legal method; the meaning of legal regulations was clarified in the process of interpreting the legal norms of family and other branch legislation, this allowed to substantiate the conclusions formulated in the work; as a result of relying on the historical and legal method, the author was able to trace the evolution of scientific ideas about dualism in law, about the independence of family law as a branch of law, etc. In addition, the inter-branch method was of great importance for this study since it allowed to account for the inter-branch links between the family law and the related branches of law. Results: it was proved that revealing the public-legal or private-law focus of the protected interest makes it possible to determine the legal nature of family legal relations that corresponds to this interest. Conclusions: the heuristic and methodological significance of dividing law into private and public for modern family law doctrine is clarified; the fundamental impossibility is proved of identifying the family legal relations as those unambiguously having public or private nature; specific examples show the critical importance of interest in determining private or public law effects on public relations; evidence is presented of the independence of the family law as an individual element of the Russian legal system; the real need for a legal definition of the “family» is substantiated.

Keywords: dualism in law; family legal relationship; legally protected interest; criterion value of interest; balance of private and public interests; legal family law legal terminology; the concept of  the “family».

IV. INTERNATIONAL LAW SCIENCES

Kazemi Shariat Panahi L. International Nuclear Law: The Nature and Complexities

📑Download article

For citation:

Kazemi Shariat Panahi L. International Nuclear Law: The Nature and Complexities. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 251–276. (In In Eng.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-251-276.

 

INTERNATIONAL NUCLEAR LAW: NATURE AND COMPLEXITIES

L. Kazemi Shariat Panahi

Law Institute, People Friendship University of Russia (RUDN)

E-mail: louise.kazemi@gmail.com

Received 20 Dec 2024

 

Introduction: Reflecting the discussion on the position of Nuclear/atomic law within the system of international law, this article argues that international nuclear law has been developed into an independent branch of public international law, being a particular set of principles and norms acknowledged by the international community of States. Further, the article also discusses certain aspects of mutual relationships between nuclear law and other legal disciplines, such as international security law, international environmental law, law of international relations. Purpose: The author seeks to analyze the various aspects of international nuclear law. Methods: The author uses a comparison analysis in the content of legal documents to discover the origin, nature, potentials, and complexities of international nuclear law. Results: The author examines how distinct principles and frameworks of nuclear law evolved to govern the peaceful use of nuclear energy, while also addressing the complex interactions with other legal domains that are impacted by nuclear activities. Conclusion: Finally, in the article the author highlights the growing significance of nuclear law as a specialized field of study and practice, driven by the expanding global reliance on nuclear power and the need for comprehensive legal oversight in this critical energy sector.

 

Keywords: international law; international nuclear law; international environmental law, ICJ; nuclear security; nuclear safety; nuclear liability; state responsibility; transboundary harms.

Muntian M.E. International Law Aspects of Space Traffic Management

📑Download article

For citation:

Muntian M. E. Mezhdunarodno-pravovye aspekty upravleniya kosmicheskim dvizheniem [International Law Aspects of Space Traffic Management]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridi- cal Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 277–302. (In Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-277-302.

 

INTERNATIONAL LEGAL ASPECTS OF SPACE TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT

 

M.E. Muntian

ANO Research Center «Space Economy and Policy»

MGIMO University

E-mail: m.e.muntyan@yandex.ru

 

Introduction: the increasing number of space objects in orbit and the absence of uniform international standards for space traffic management pose a threat to the safety of spaceflight and increase the risk of debris formation. In light of modern technical and economic developments, it is essential to develop a legal framework for the regulation of space traffic. The purpose of the article is to analyze the legal aspects of international space traffic management, examining relevant international space law and identifying key components of a potential legal regime. It also assesses current initiatives in this field and explores the prospects for their implementation based on ongoing discussions within the UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space. Methods: the comparative legal method and legal and doctrinal analysis were applied in this work, along with the study of international treaties, national legislation, doctrinal sources, and initiatives from international organizations. Results: it has been determined that current international space law lacks a comprehensive mechanism for managing space traffic. Two potential models for its development are being considered: a “bottom-up” approach (harmonizing national regulations) and a “top-down” approach (creating a universal international agreement). The proposals of the International Academy of Astronautics and the UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space were analyzed, including ideas for enhancing situational awareness in space and utilizing ICAO’s experience in coordinating space flights. Conclusions: The establishment of an international legal framework for space traffic management necessitates the development of unified international standards, including rules for maneuvering, a system for data exchange, and mechanisms for legal liability. Further research should consider not only the interests of spacefaring nations, but also those of developing states, and technological developments in order to guarantee the safety and sustainability of space activities.

 

Keywords: outer space, space traffic management, international space law, space situational awareness, space navigation, space traffic coordination, space debris, international responsibility.

Proroković D.N., Željski R.B. Creative Interpretation of International Law and the Status of Kosovo in International Relations

📑Download article

For citation:

Proroković D. N., Željski R. B. Creative Interpretation of International Law and the Status of Kosovo in International Relations. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Juridicheskie nauki – Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences. 2025. Issue 2(68). Pp. 303–313. DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2025-68-303-313.

 

CREATIVE INTERPRETATION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND THE STATUS OF KOSOVO IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS

 

D. Proroković

Institute of International Politics and Economics, Belgrade (Serbia)

E-mail: dusan@diplomacy.bg.ac.rs

 

R.B. Željski

National Security Academy, Belgrade (Serbia)

E-mail: relliusmc@yahoo.com

 

Received 4 Apr 2025

 

Introduction: The case of Kosovo’s unilateral declaration of independence in 2008 is specific in many ways. Although some Western politicians and/or theorists claim that it is sui generis, the only thing that represents a unique example in this process is precisely the creative interpretations of international law. Creative interpretations of international law by the US and the EU created a new political reality and thanks to this, the case of Kosovo has become more complex than before. Purpose: An attempt to explain the key events that determined the resolution of the status of Kosovo. This explanation actually proves how necessary it is to scrupulously insist on the provisions of international law and respect for signed agreements in order to resolve complex political conflicts. Creative interpretations have not contributed to the resolution of the conflict, but have created patterns and potential for new confrontations. Methods: theoretical methods of analysis, synthesis, modeling, analogy; empirical methods of description, interpretation; special scientific methods: historical method, method of legal norms interpretation. Results: The analyzed events indicate that legal norms were interpreted and contextualized in a way that suited the geopolitical goals of the US and the EU. Such interpretations and contextualizations were necessary for the US and the EU to portray the process of declaring Kosovo’s independence as legal and so that they could lobby for Kosovo’s recognition in international relations. Conclusion: Creative interpretations of international law, relying on political pressure and threats of force (or the use of armed forces), have not contributed to resolving the Kosovo case in the way the US and the EU wanted. More than half of the UN member states still do not recognize Kosovo, and the question of legitimizing the status of this entity remains open. However, at the same time, the US and the EU have created an unpleasant precedent that can now be (mis)used elsewhere in the world. Their actions have also significantly undermined the authority of international organizations such as the UN and the International Court of Justice, which may be a bad thing for overall international relations.

 

Keywords: Kosovo, secession, unilateral proclamation, Serbia, FR Yugoslavia, international law, USA, EU.